Let's go back to Minh's story from the previous post. At the end of the year, Minh hired a CPA to prepare his tax returns. The CPA sent Minh a set of financial statements and said, "The net profit is 150 million, Minh."
Minh thanked him, and then... did nothing with it. Just like 99% of other small business owners.
But if Minh knew about BSA, he would examine that report himself and discover many things:
Step 1: Check the Money – “Does the account balance match the bank statement?”
|
Category
|
Record
|
Reality
|
|
Cash in hand
|
15 millions
|
15 millions
|
|
Tiền gửi Vietcombank
|
43 millions
|
43 millions
|
|
Số dư ví Shopee
|
30 millions
|
28 millions
|
There's a 2 million VND discrepancy in Shopee wallet. Why? It could be an unrecorded return. It's a small amount – but if left unchecked, it will accumulate into a large sum.
Step 2: Inventory Check – “Does the item actually exist? Is the value correct?”
The balance sheet shows inventory at 300 million. Minh conducted the inventory check and discovered:
|
Type of goods
|
Original value
|
Real value
|
|
Best-selling products (cosmetics)
|
180 million
|
180 million
|
|
Slow-moving inventory (imported 6 months ago, only 20% sold)
|
70 million
|
~50 million
|
|
Dead goods (expired, outdated, defective)
|
50 million
|
~5 million
|
|
Total
|
300 million
|
235 million
|
Difference: 65 million. On paper, Minh has 300 million worth of inventory. In reality, it's only 235 million. This means the 150 million profit reported by CPA is also incorrect – the actual profit is only about 85 million.
Note: This is an extremely common mistake made by e-commerce sellers: recording inventory at purchase price, but never reassessing its true value. Outdated, expired, returned goods – all remain on the books as “assets.” But in reality, they are junk.
Step 3: Check Accounts Receivable – “Who owes me money?”
The balance sheet shows accounts receivable of 80 million. Minh reviewed it:
• Unpaid Shopee payment: 45 million VND (will be received within 7 days)
• Unpaid TikTok Shop balance: 20 million VND
• Amount owed to agent A: 15 million VND – overdue for 6 months, no contact possible (likely lost).
So the actual receivable is only 65 million, not 80 million. Plus another 15 million in "fictitious assets" on the books.
Step 4: Check Accounts Payable – “Who do I owe money to, and how much?”
The balance sheet shows a payable of 360 million. Minh checked and found:
• Debt to Korean suppliers: 150 million
• Bank loans: 200 million
• Unpaid taxes: recorded as 10 million, but CPA undercalculated personal income tax → actual tax is approximately 18 million
Actual debt: 368 million. The debt is 8 million more than what is recorded in the books..
Step 5: Recalculate Equity – “How much do I actually have?”
Equity = Real Assets – Real Liabilities
|
|
According to CPA records
|
According to Minh's BSA
|
|
Total assets
|
630 million
|
548 million
|
|
Total liabilities
|
360 million
|
368 million
|
|
Owner's Equity
|
270 million
|
180 million
|
The CPA said the equity was 270 million. In reality, it was only 180 million – a difference of 90 million, or one-third!
Minh didn't need to study auditing to do this. He just needed to: reconcile cash with the bank, conduct an inventory check, review accounts receivable, and check taxes. Five simple steps, but they accomplished something the CPA wouldn't do for you.